Business Insurance
Menu
View all articles

Getting More Out of Total Rewards Programs

The War for Talent is alive and well. Insatiable demand for talent, coupled with limited supply, a new working paradigm and turbulent market conditions, place immense pressure on organizations to ensure their people programs are up to snuff and flexible enough to manage through ongoing change. This dynamic creates a renewed focus on Total Rewards.

Changing Mindset from “Compensation + Benefits” to Total Rewards

It’s easy to get caught in the trap of measuring total rewards competitiveness through each of its parts. Is my employee benefits program competitive? Is my cash compensation program competitive? Is my equity program competitive? Is my remote work and employee flexibility policy competitive? These are all valid questions but fail to acknowledge that each of these components are interconnected and the sum is greater than its parts, for good or ill! Shifting to a total rewards mindset enables a clear understanding of higher-level choices and trade-offs that exist to enable flexibility and optimize program effectiveness for each company’s unique set of circumstances.

Well Designed Total Rewards Starts with the Business

As with all thoughtful people programs, Total Rewards must be grounded in the business. What is the business plan for the foreseeable future? What is the implication for results, our desired culture and behaviors that will reinforced through our human capital programs?

Establishing a philosophy that directly links to the strategy is a great place to start and should consider foundational criteria such as:

  • A shared definition of success
  • Clear program objectives
  • Desired culture
  • Market definition
  • Desired competitive positioning
  • Affordability
  • Company constraints

When designed properly, the Total Rewards framework should permeate the business – from the company’s underlying job architecture, to organizational incentive design, to deliberate choices made relating to coverage and cost sharing, to performance management and differentiation.

Getting More Out of Total Rewards

Beyond philosophy and market competitiveness, there are two fundamental considerations to Total Rewards:

  1. How well are the programs valued?
  2. How much do the programs cost?

When programs are evaluated in isolation, we tend to focus on the external lens (i.e., “market” vs. internal value) and lose the concept of fungibility between elements of the total rewards program.

Given how much the world has changed in recent times (remote or hybrid work, social justice issues, generational change in the workforce, etc.) there is now a desire for control and choice by employees. How do we assign a value to our programs? This can vary from informal conversations to flash surveys to conjoint analysis. Regardless of the approach, incorporating perceived value (whether qualitative or quantitative) into the program design is a critically important input. This exercise also exposes areas where education and/or communication opportunities exist to bolster program value.

To the extent we can assign a relative value to each program, and we know the cost of running that program, it enables us to have a very different conversation around effectiveness and maximizing ROI for employees and for the company in a way that can be tailored for each situation.

Consider the following framework:

Newfront Alpine total rewards framework

The Power of Getting Total Rewards Right

For those that “get it right,” we see significant downstream benefits such as higher employee engagement, lower voluntary turnover and higher retention rates. While there is no such thing as a perfect Total Rewards program, business alignment, external competitiveness, internal value, total spend, improved communication and a holistic viewpoint are core elements that will ensure program effectiveness, flexibility and well-spend dollars.

For more information, contact your Newfront advisor.


About the author

Alpine Rewards

Alpine Rewards is a strategic advisor for the Technology and Life Sciences sectors, providing comprehensive expertise in Executive Compensation and Employee Rewards. Industry experience, coupled with a direct linkage to business strategy and a focus on people, enable Alpine Rewards to design Total Rewards programs for a higher purpose.


The information provided is of a general nature and an educational resource. It is not intended to provide advice or address the situation of any particular individual or entity. Any recipient shall be responsible for the use to which it puts this document. Newfront shall have no liability for the information provided. While care has been taken to produce this document, Newfront does not warrant, represent or guarantee the completeness, accuracy, adequacy, or fitness with respect to the information contained in this document. The information provided does not reflect new circumstances, or additional regulatory and legal changes. The issues addressed may have legal, financial, and health implications, and we recommend you speak to your legal, financial, and health advisors before acting on any of the information provided.

Share this article

Keep up to date with Newfront News and Events—

Recommended reading

Protect Against Unwanted Action Over Claims

July 6th 2022

View all articles